The year 2013 has definitely brought about a shift in cultural consciousness. For the last year, our culture and media have finally started to critically examine rape culture and the prevalence of sexism, harassment and sexual assault worldwide. We were horrified by the tragic events in Steubenville and New Delhi, India. These assaults touched and angered so many of us and triggered an urgent call not just for dialogue and awareness, but also, for education and systemic change. To that end, the Title IX movement, which is working to fight campus rape culture, launched earlier this year. Its mission is to work to “support all survivors, to change how colleges and universities handle sexual assault, and to change a culture where violence is normalized.” Survivors and allies have filed federal Title IX and Clery Act complaints at various universities in the U.S. for not providing the needed resources and for covering up rape when it happens.
For the last year I have wanted to add my voice to those who are covering these movements, but I knew I needed to learn more before I wrote about such an important issue in the public sphere. So I read and researched like crazy, and most importantly, listened to the hundreds of survivors who told me their stories. Even though I was thrilled by the increased visibility of this issue in the mainstream media, as I gained more knowledge I started to become frustrated with the vast amount of misinformation being propagated by our media and culture at large. A few weeks ago, I finally felt ready to co-author a piece on the media framing of teenage sexual violence for The Huffington Post. I am publishing the slightly longer version here, along with related articles and research that go beyond media framing to provide resources for parents, teens, and educators to end sexual violence. This will be the first of several pieces on sexual violence.
Last month, teenager Daisy Coleman bravely wrote a piece that detailed how another student from her hometown of Maryville, Missouri raped her and videotaped the assault. Her story echoes a familiar pattern of other high-profile cases involving teenagers, such as the Steubenville, Louisville, and Saratoga cases. While we find it encouraging that the mainstream media has been covering these cases, too much of the coverage has dismissed substantive research in favor of perpetuating various myths about young people and sexual assault.
We need journalists to re-frame the tone and questions that guide their reporting. The majority of the pieces covering teen sexual violence fall into superficial tropes that focus on the role of alcohol, the victim’s clothes, and sexting by “impulse-driven teens.” By fixating on sexting instead of what these teens are truly doing, which is “sexual assaultexting,” the media detracts from the fact that these boys are choosing to sexually assault another person and then shame them through social media.
Additionally, many journalists use language that deflects blame from the rapists and subtly shapes how readers understand teen sexual violence. Journalists tend to use passive phrasing, such as “she was raped,” which is problematic because it does not focus on the person who committed the crime. Too frequently, these cases are referred to as “scandals,” which only serves to sensationalize what happened while simultaneously obscuring that it was actually a crime. Often media coverage relies on terms that imply consent, such as “engaging in” and “sexual activity,” indicating a lack of knowledge about what constitutes rape. Ultimately, the way in which journalists cover teen sexual violence reflects a societal reluctance to label teenage boys as perpetrators.
These narratives support the “boys will be boys” myth that results in blaming the victim and the idea that teenage boys cannot be held truly accountable for their actions. Perhaps this explains why, in the coverage of the Steubenville rape case, reporters from multiple media outlets slanted their focus to be sympathetic to the rapists and blamed the victim. Who can forget CNN reporters expressing how “difficult” it was to hear the perpetrators convicted of rape crying in the courtroom, because their “promising lives” had fallen apart? But what about the life of the girl who they assaulted, who has to live with the rape for the rest of her life? This question is often absent from mainstream media coverage.
What we find so frustrating about this kind of reporting is that it ignores the fact that research has revealed the extent to which rape is a calculated and premeditated crime. Several studies have concluded that young people are able to understand refusals in many different contexts. Thus these cases are not accidents or miscommunications as the mainstream media often suggests: they are a result of boys not respecting a girl’s lack of consent. Understanding that perpetrators have specific attitudes, beliefs, worldviews, and cognitive frameworks that shape their decisions to override this consent and that need to be addressed by comprehensive socialization and education” is a different framework than what the media usually defaults to, which is that these young rapists are simply confused boys who rape by “accident.”
Additionally, while journalists often focus on the victim’s consumption of alcohol as causing sexual assault, research shows how perpetrators use alcohol as a tool to facilitate rape. Therefore, when media coverage focuses on the alcohol usage of victims, they are giving rapists the social license to operate because these men know that women who are drinking are seen as less credible when they report sexual assault.
Furthermore, research on college rapists mirrors studies of convicted sex offenders, which reveals that the majority of rapists are serial predators who often begin committing sexual violence as adolescents. Thus the cases we see in the news aren’t accidents or a ‘blip’ on a boy’s otherwise flawless record — they are more often than not the start of a long career as a serial rapist.
Given this research, it is distressing that articles that cover teen sexual violence pay little attention to how we fail to educate teenagers in ways that actually prevent sexual assault, such as comprehensive health education at school and in the home that focuses on teaching sexual respect and what constitutes sexual consent. Journalists need to work on reframing how we understand sexual violence prevention, because the research clearly shows that the only thing that causes sexual violence is someone choosing to assault another person. There needs to be an emphasis on preventative education which has been proven again and again to be a successful tool in helping to cut sexual assault rates amongst young people.
The tragedy of many of these cases goes far beyond the crime of sexual assault. It is also the dozens of young people who witnessed them and did nothing. We need to teach adolescents to act ethically in these situations. With bystander education, in which individuals are taught how to intervene when they see someone in trouble, these cases could have been prevented. Media coverage should stress the importance of bystander education as a successful way to empower young people to stop rape. Examples of noteworthy programs include the New York State Department of Health’s toolkit for bystander intervention and the University of New Hampshire’s Know Your Power campaign.
Most importantly, what needs to be clear in media coverage of teen sexual violence is that sexting, alcohol, and the Internet do not cause rape. The true issues at hand in these cases are disregard for other people’s bodily autonomy and lack of empathy for sexual assault survivors. Until those working in the media understand this, misconceptions regarding teen sexual assault will continue to be perpetuated to a wider audience.
When journalists ignore the research on sexual violence and toolkits about how to properly cover sexual assault and instead resort to superficial and sensationalist reporting, they are hurting efforts to end teen sexual violence. The media should not only do a better job when covering these stories, but also work to help educate and shape public opinion about what works to stop sexual assault. We owe it to young women like Daisy Coleman to accurately tell their stories and be allies in fighting sexual violence.
Resources for Teens:
Want to take action? Check out the I will End Sexual Violence and love is respect campaigns, as well as the Representation Project and SPARK movement to see how you can get involved in ending not just sexual violence, but the sexualization and objectification of young people in the media!
Resources for Parents:
The Conversation You Must Have With Your Sons
Hey Teenage Boys! Worried About Steubenville? Don’t Be.
Boys Will Be Boys, But Not Always Men
What To Tell The Next Generation
In Steubvenville Rape Case, a Lesson For Adults
Additional Resources for Educators:
The Effectiveness of Empathy-Based Rape Prevention and Bystander Training
Importance of Targeting Intervention at Teens
Five Creative Ways That Students Are Fighting Rape Culture
Why People Don’t Intervene When They Witness a Sexual Assault, and How We Can Change That
General Resources on Sexual Violence and Rape Culture:
Mapping a Global Pandemic: Sexual Violence Against Women
This Is What Rape Culture Looks Like
How Slut Shaming Becomes Victim Blaming
The Five Ways Sexual Assault Is Really About Entitlement
My Related Posts:
14 responses to “Teen Sexual Violence: What Our Media and Culture Is Missing”
Excellent article, thank you! Journalistic integrity and intelligence and sensitivity is so important, yet so lacking, and perpetuating a rape and violent culture is one end product. The media is a huge culture-shaper, and journalists, who disseminate very important messages, are chosen mostly on the basis of how they LOOK (on TV anyway) vs. their skill and talent (as long as it aligns with status quo, its all good!). Same with police, who have such an important job to protect the public, are only required to be strong and able-bodied to land their job, but ZERO expectation for them to have any type of meaningful intelligence (and education in cop school leaves much to be desired) —-> this is why so many crime victims are grossly let down (whether its teenagers who’ve been raped or girls/women in the sex trade or wives/gf’s who’ve been beaten — police do hardly anything to protect victims in these situations, never mind prevent such horrors from happening! Its outrageous and unacceptable!
I really appreciate the education pieces you added and look forward to checking out the links. Thanks again for a great piece, I’m off to share it on fb. 🙂
Thank you so much for your response! So good to hear from you 🙂 I completely agree with what you said and I especially love what you said about the media supporting the status quo. Most media organizations are now owned by five corporations who place a tremendous amount of pressure on these outlets to produce ratings and sensationalist beats in favor of more in depth, critical news coverage. It’s pretty depressing.
Thank you for sharing! By the way, something was wrong with my first link, so I had to re-publish it. You might have to repost it on your wall again or else the people who click on your link might not be able to access it!
Good to connect with you. 🙂 Good point about most media orgs being owned by 5 mega corporations — it IS depressing — what gives me hope and excitement is minds like yours and blogs like this where actual thinking and meaningful conversation takes place and is encouraged. Pre-internet, society was way more dependent on status quo “news” and one had to put a lot of effort to find “alternative” thinking. Things have really shifted with the internet. The challenge now is sifting through all the info out there and coming across thought-gems like here. It is really refreshing and inspiring for me to read and dialogue with sensitive, thinking people who have integrity, as there seem to be quite a lot of us out there! Power to The People, which we must yank away from the bastard bully status quo profiteers! 😉
Oh and thanx for the heads-up re. the links — duly noted (I have to still check them out).
Reblogged this on The Feminist Rag and commented:
Excellent article by Nadia worth reading, including some good links provided throughout to learn more, including two pro-active prevention/education programs for this very preventable cultural horror show. We create our culture; it’s up to us to change it.
Thank you so much for the reblog! 🙂
And for your sweet words regarding my blog being a ‘thought-gem’. Best compliment EVER! 🙂
Aww, you’re welcome and it’s true! You’re a great thinker and writer! 🙂
Thank you! You are too! 🙂
You are too! Love your blog, so glad we connected!! 🙂
Me too girlfriend! 🙂
Pingback: Teen Sexual Violence: What Our Media and Culture Is Missing | outspoken.
Reblogged this on outspoken. and commented:
An excellent blog post from my friend Nadia.
Pingback: How Faculty Can Use Syllabi to Help Reduce Campus Sexual Assault | Listen Girlfriends!